Je me baladais sur Tv Tropes quand j'ai lu une espèce de mini-théorie que j'avais jamais vue (et pas ici en tout cas) et qui me parait vachement intéressante. Je la mets ici parce que ça me paraît être un endroit approprié (et que je savais pas où la mettre autrement):
Quelqu'un sur TV Tropes a écrit:
On the subject of 'leaving traces', there's already been evidence that Imu erased a location from the map shown once before...at Enies Lobby, a massive hole in the middle of the sea that looks like somebody gouged out a massive chunk of the world and left a scar that never healed, a hole that never fills up with seawater no matter how much flows into it and the sun never stops shining over it, almost like the natural laws of the world were effected by whatever erased the land that stood there before. At the time it was chalked up to another quirk of One Piece's weird geography, but if the same phenomenon was repeated elsewhere, then it becomes evidence that something is capable of deliberately causing these 'impact craters'. Tellingly, nothing is shown of the aftermath of what Lulusia looks like after Imu erased it, only a shot of the surrounding oceans, likely because said sight would be markedly familiar to readers.
Indeed, if one looks at the actual hole at Enies Lobby, they'll notice its shape is markedly oblong, and Enies Lobby itself was noted to be located close to the Red Line and Mary Geoise, the 'home of the gods'. Such a location may indeed once have been a prime candidate for somebody to term the island that was once there 'God Valley', serving as a metaphorical front-door to the land of the gods. Of everything seen on the island before the Buster Call, nothing appears to be markedly ancient or something that couldn't have been built over a period of 10-20 years of back-breaking labour, and it would fit what we've seen of the WG's Modus Operandi to erase whatever stood there, such as the site of a publicly-embarrassing, yet historical fight, and build over with with a new history and function to obscure what was erased.
Traduction rapide: Enies Lobby, avec son gouffre surnaturel, ne serait en fait pas une curiosité naturelle comme tout le monde le pense (dans le manga et en dehors), mais la marque d'une ancienne île effacée par Uranus sous le contrôle d'Imu. Et, pour aller plus loin, (et là j'y crois moins), l'ancien nom d'Enies Lobby serait celui de la seule autre île qui a "disparu" sans laisser de trace: God Valley.
Voilà, donc moi j'ai lu la première partie j'étais en mode:

Et je vous laisse avec ça
